Absolutely loved the pizzas at Little Italy Pizzeria Cafe! We ordered three pizzas - Rustica, Sicilica, and Marinara—all recommended by the staff member, and every single one was delicious! Really enjoyed the food and the overall experience. Would definitely visit again and highly recommend this place to anyone who loves good pizza! 🍕
The pepperoni pizza is the way to go. Italian style pepperoni with a tasteful and savory flavor. The pizza is cooked well with a floppy underside. One thing that could’ve made the pizza better is allowing the bottom to be a bit more crunchy so the pizza isn’t so floppy but the flavor makes up for this.
Secondly, the cheesecake is amazing. We got the chocolate cheesecake pictured here and it is only second to my favorite cheesecake spot in NYC.
A bonus point is the staff is enjoyable and conversational.
This was a great little place. The food was amazing and the service was even better. The guy front of the house was so great he even ran to the store to get us oat milk for our cappuccinos! We had a caprese, penne ala vodka and goat cheese bruschetta. All wonderful. Highly recommend this little place!
We needed a break from Pub fare and stopped here for dinner this evening. Very happy with the food and service! I had the Diavola pizza and my wife had the tortellini with meat sauce. Our son ordered the meat pizza along with house side salads.
Our server was super friendly and food came out promptly. Pizzas were great - thin crust pies cooked perfectly with plenty of spice. My wife’s tortellini was clearly home made and the sauce was hearty.
As others have noted, they don’t serve any alcohol, so plan ahead and bring a bottle or stop by the market on the corner.
Very very good italian food and a nice waiter. Would always recommend! If you’ve had enough irish food, this is a great place to eat a different type of cuisine!